What do i do if i purchase one webkinz plush and got two of the same pets with one code?

I have a problem. I recently purchased a webkinz baby penguin plush. When I signed her in I went home and discovered I had received two virtual baby penguins! They have the same name and the same gender! The only difference is their profiles. I received two pet specific gifts and double the kinzcash was awarded, it was like I had adopted two of the same pets with one code! Someone help! D:

I think you need two codes. One code for each pet.